A Gay Dad Sounds Off About the Iowa Moms and an Unthinkable Tragedy


As a gay dad, I have heard the words a thousand times.  “A child is better off with both a mother and a father”.  The statement always baffles me. Certainly, no two sets of parents of any make up are identically equipped, so is the theory that any opposite sex parents are better than any same sex parents?

The anti-gays claim that to be the case.  Right wing spokespeople have gone so far as to declare that even orphanages are superior to same sex parents.  The Catholic Church has previously declared that same sex parents were doing “violence” to the children in their care.

I don’t believe my life supports the concept.  I have two sons.  Each was born to a heterosexual couple and due to personal issues, each of them would have died had they remained with their birth parents.  That is not conjecture, that is fact.

Drug addiction plagued all four of my sons’ birth parents.  With the life I was able to give them, my sons are happy, healthy well adjusted eleven year old boys.   

Sadly, in the most devastating of ways, a couple of mothers in Iowa will have no such happy ending. Rachel and Heidi McFarland had a baby boy named Gabriel since his birth.  Within days of when the adoption was to finalize, the sixteen year old birth mother changed her mind.  Rachel and Heidi became what the Des Moines Register called “former adoptive parents “.

I know the taste of that crushing and painful experience.  On the road to adopting my two sons, there were periods of time when one of each of their adoptions were called into question.  Should I have lost either of them, I would have dearly wanted to believe that the child I was losing was going to the possibility of a good and happy life, even if I was not privileged to be his parent.   In my loss, the love I felt for my child would have placed him first beyond my own desires.

Surely this was the case for the moms of little Gabriel.  The moms had spent every waking moment with him caring for his every need, from the moment of his birth to the moment where they lost him.    Ultimately, that didn’t matter.

“We had been scrutinized,  our life style has been scrutinized, the people in our lives have been scrutinized,  we had to have letters of reference for this home study, to make sure we were…adequate as parents,” said Rachel.  “And, they never had to have anything when they took him back.”

Little boy Gabriel went back to the “a child is better off with a mother and a father” ideal, to two teenagers.  It was under a teen boy’s care, while the birth teen mom was running errands, that Gabriel lost his life.  He was alone when he was found.

His moms heard about his death… by listening to the news.

Gabriel did not die because his moms were lesbian.  His death was not the byproduct of homophobia.  His fate was not because of a violation of any legal custody issues.  His story is bigger than any of that.  His story is about love, sacrifice and the true meaning of being a parent.  His story is one that brings the bigoted preconceived notions around same sex parenting to its knees.

When I heard the story of Rachel and Heidi, I wept over what had happened to them.  This is my letter from a dad to two moms. 

Dear Rachel and Heidi,

I will not pretend that I know what you are going through.  Even though I possess  the over abiding love for my two sons, and a distant but constant fear that something bad could ever happen to them, I have never experienced the pain I can only imagine you feel today.

You are both such magnificent women, and you have experienced what is arguably life’s most ultimate loss.  I wish I could say that my note here was one to cheer you, or even give you comfort.  Sadly, it is not.

This is a note that validates your pain, anguish, horror and sorrow. There are those in this world who see you as bystanders, mere caretakers who were there for a few months and then cut loose.  I know the truth.  You are mothers who have lost a great and significant love.  You lost Gabriel, in a deeper, more profound way than anyone else.

You were the parents who held the hope and promise for a  little boy, and he was blessed by your wonderful glow.  Life is precious and fragile, and the disastrous events that happened were made possible by just a few childish decisions by two people who had no business being parents at all.  Again, we, the world, need to see that procreating a human child and being his parent are not one and the same thing.

I desperately wish I could make this better for you.  I  want that I could have that kind of power, because this is exactly a situation in which I would use it.  But, I don’t and I can’t .  You are in my thoughts and prayer.  I put out the hope that the love you have within your family can carry you through this loss, and eventually deliver your next child, who will be so fortunate and blessed to have you.

Your little Gabriel was born deaf in one ear.  You fitted him for a hearing aide.  There was a fear he might become entirely deaf.   You both started to learn sign language. 

In the end, there was no one in your family that was hard of hearing.   It was the world.  The world did not recognize that a love and dedication strong enough to put your child before your own needs earned you the right to motherhood. This is your tragedy and loss,.  You gave our world clarity.  You have defined true parenting more clearly than it has been understood before.

I fill my heart with love and solidarity.  You are not “former”, you are not “adoptive”.   You are real moms in every way that counts.

In a few weeks, it will be Mothers Day.  On that day, I will buy two roses to honor you.  I will look on them and think of you, as you are: 

Gabriel’s Moms, now and forever.


Please like the evoL= Facebook page here.

Follow us on Twitter @ JandJDad




About robw77

A single gay dad who cares. His story can be read here: http://www.imagaysingleparent.com/2013/02/02/rob/ and here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/31/rob-watson-gay-family_n_4689661.html
This entry was posted in Prejudice and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

22 Responses to A Gay Dad Sounds Off About the Iowa Moms and an Unthinkable Tragedy

  1. Chrissy says:

    This is why, even as a right-wing conservative, I still fully support LGBT causes. I believe loving parents, in any case, is far more important than heterosexual parents.

  2. Jan Hobbs says:

    Reblogged this on Blissfully Single and commented:
    I have no words, only tears. 😢

  3. Pingback: Why I Want Pope Francis to Write the Requiem for Gabriel Fernandez, the Boy Slaughtered by His Parents for Appearing Gay | evoL =

  4. Pingback: A Gay Dad’s Open Letter to the Christian Grandmother Proposing Homophobic Themed Books for Teens | evoL =

  5. Pingback: Unthinkable tragedy | Epenthesis

  6. apeene says:

    So eloquently written. Thank you for putting words to this tragedy in a way that lifts up those who have been affected by it. Love, love, love to you Rob!

  7. Rebecca garrett says:

    I am Rachel’s mother and Gabriel’s grandmother. I just want to thank you so much for the love and kindness that you sent to my girls. They are magnificent women for so many reasons and they were the perfect mamas for Gabe. My heart is so heavy with grief I can barely express myself, but I wanted you to know that I keep reading your blog over and over again feeling more peace within my soul each time. Gabe’s death has served to catapult me into action in getting some changes added to the present day adoption laws. When I’m strong again and begin my battle I would like you by my side so that other adoptive parents and innocent babies don’t have to experience what my daughters, family, and friends are going through now. Thanks again, Rebecca Garrett

    • robw77 says:

      Thank you Rebecca so much for your note, and all, all, all my love to your girls. To think that this piece is giving you some comfort, touches me deeply. Yes, when you are feeling stronger, and want to make a change, let me know, I am now, and will be then..by your side.

  8. Kathleen Walters says:

    That was beautiful. A very touching tribute to a very sad story. My heart goes out to those 2 women who truly are mothers in every sense. I will also think of them on Mother’s Day.

  9. kerry dempster says:

    To Joanne a merried hetrosexual I Had a friend who was , with his brother. Who had hetrosexual mother and father , but so sad , my friend and his bother are lots , drugs addicted.
    totally dependent on their next fix , because they were put in home after home after home , with no love , Why were they put in to all these homes , well because there real father . fond there
    real mother with there fathers brother . so the father shot with and brother in front of his children , OH I had very love parents and 2 brother and 4 sister . my Name is
    Kerry Dempster

  10. No one could have said this better. Wonderfully written. Now if only those that need to, would read it.

  11. Joanne says:

    What a heart wrenching event. Anyone can make a baby. It takes true guts, determination, devotion and pure love to raise a child. Whether you are gay, straight, bi, transgender, black, white, Asian. All these words mean nothing. Love is love. Only a true and pure heart can be a good parent. I wish the same laws and rigorous checks where given to every parent like they are to adoptive parents. Maybe less children would then be left to die, abused, tortured and killed. Sending my love to. X

  12. keith says:

    One needs to have a license to keep a dog, drive a car, go fishing, but any two people can make a baby. This does not make them parents.

  13. moodymoons says:

    Thanks for sharing this.

  14. Enrico says:

    Reblogged this on Blue Manatee and commented:
    L’orrore e la brutalità di questi fatti non stupisce più di tanto purtroppo. Credo che di fronte a tanto dolore non avrei più freni nel sopportare le ingiustizie che ci vengono inflitte come coltellate indifferenti.

    Ho la pelle d’oca per quel povero bambino e per quelle povere mamme. Vorrei osservare un lutto stretto, ma è come se la nostra vita non fosse cosparsa di altro, ultimamente, come se non indossassi altro che nero catrame mentre leggo queste notizie. Ecco che l’odio di cui siamo bersaglio viene trasferito – come sempre la via più facile e più vigliacca è punire chi ci sta vicino – su innocenti.

  15. swo8 says:

    Dear Evol,
    With the devotion and care that children will need, thank heavens you were there to step in for them.

  16. Joni bosch says:

    I know a couple other gay moms in Iowa. They, too , lost a child to death because they adopted a very sick and multiply handicapped little precious. I have such high regard for those who are willing to adopt. I have serious qualms about overturning adoptions.

  17. felinewyvern says:

    I have often said that, if they gave natural parents the kind of scrutiny adoptive parents get, there would be far less cruelty to, and abuse of, children in the world. It has been proven time after time that just being the birth parent does not make you a proper mother of father, and the sooner the world accepts that the better for all children.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s